How to Build Trust as a Leader and Strengthen Your Team
Featuring Matt Davis of True Bold Leadership
Trust isn't created by a title. It's earned through consistent actions, honest communication, and a genuine commitment to serving others.
In Episode 64 of Elevate Your Call to Service, Mike and Cathy McIntosh sit down with Matt Davis, founder of True Bold Leadership, to discuss why trust is the foundation of every healthy organization. Drawing from his experience in law enforcement and leadership development, Matt explains how great leaders intentionally build trust, communicate with clarity, and create cultures where people feel valued and empowered.
Rather than focusing on authority, this conversation challenges leaders to think differently about influence. Trust begins long before a crisis—and it starts with the leader.
Whether you supervise one employee or an entire organization, you'll leave this conversation with practical ideas you can immediately apply to strengthen your leadership and your team.
The Leadership Challenge
Every organization wants engaged employees, healthy culture, and strong performance.
Yet many leaders focus on improving the team before examining themselves.
Trust is built—or broken—through everyday leadership behaviors:
Following through on commitments
Communicating consistently
Listening before reacting
Owning mistakes
Demonstrating integrity when no one is watching
When trust increases, communication improves, accountability becomes healthier, and organizations become stronger.
In This Episode
Why trust is the foundation of every successful team
The relationship between self-trust and leadership confidence
The four pillars of trust every leader should understand
Why communication determines organizational culture
Matt Davis' BELIEVE Leadership Framework
How to recognize and build on the strengths within your team
Four practical questions every leader should regularly ask employees
Leadership Lessons from Matt Davis
1. Leadership Begins With Yourself
The trust your team has in you often reflects the trust you've built within yourself. Self-awareness and personal integrity are foundational leadership skills.
2. Trust Is Built Daily
People don't decide whether to trust a leader during one defining moment. Trust grows—or erodes—through hundreds of everyday interactions.
3. Communication Creates Culture
Clear, honest communication establishes expectations, reduces uncertainty, and strengthens relationships throughout an organization.
4. Consistency Builds Credibility
Leadership isn't about occasional excellence. Consistency creates confidence, and confidence creates trust.
5. Great Leaders Notice the Bright Spots
Rather than only correcting problems, effective leaders intentionally recognize strengths and reinforce behaviors they want repeated.
6. Leaders Can Become the Bottleneck
Sometimes organizational challenges aren't caused by the team—they're created by leadership habits that unintentionally limit growth.
7. Influence Is More Powerful Than Authority
Titles grant responsibility. Trust earns influence.
8. Preparation Builds Confidence
Confident leaders aren't born—they prepare, learn, and continually develop before bigger opportunities arrive.
9. Questions Build Relationships
Curiosity demonstrates care. Leaders who ask thoughtful questions learn what motivates their people and build stronger connections.
10. Trust Is Your Greatest Leadership Asset
Policies, procedures, and strategy all matter—but trust determines whether people will willingly follow.Feedback Reveals Leadership Readiness
Memorable Quotes
"Trust isn't built by your title. It's built by your actions."
"Leadership starts with leading yourself."
"Communication doesn't just share information—it shapes culture."
"People don't follow positions. They follow leaders they trust."
About Matt Davis
Matt Davis is a law enforcement lieutenant, leadership speaker, and founder of True Bold Leadership. Through his BELIEVE Leadership Framework, Matt equips leaders to build trust, strengthen communication, and develop organizational cultures where people are motivated to contribute at their highest level.
Questions & Answers
Why is trust important in leadership?
Trust is the foundation of effective leadership. When leaders consistently demonstrate integrity, communicate clearly, and follow through on commitments, they create an environment where people feel safe to contribute, collaborate, and perform at a higher level.
Can trust be rebuilt after it's been lost?
Yes—but rebuilding trust requires consistent action over time. Leaders rebuild credibility by acknowledging mistakes, communicating honestly, taking responsibility, and demonstrating reliable behavior day after day.
What are the four pillars of trust discussed in this episode?
Matt Davis explains that trust is built through intentional leadership behaviors that create credibility, strengthen relationships, improve communication, and demonstrate consistent character. These pillars become the foundation for healthy teams and organizational culture.
How does communication affect organizational culture?
Communication shapes culture by establishing expectations, reinforcing values, and building confidence within a team. Poor communication creates uncertainty and erodes trust, while clear and consistent communication strengthens relationships and accountability.
What is the BELIEVE Leadership Framework?
The BELIEVE Leadership Framework is Matt Davis' approach to intentional leadership development. It emphasizes leading yourself first, building trust, strengthening communication, and creating cultures where people feel valued and motivated to contribute.
Why does self-leadership matter?
Leaders who understand themselves—their strengths, weaknesses, emotions, and values—are better equipped to lead others with confidence and authenticity. Self-leadership becomes the foundation for earning trust from a team.
How can leaders strengthen trust with their teams?
Trust grows through everyday leadership behaviors: listening well, following through on commitments, recognizing employees' strengths, asking meaningful questions, communicating consistently, and demonstrating integrity in both large and small decisions.
Who should listen to this episode?
This episode is valuable for supervisors, managers, executives, law enforcement leaders, public safety professionals, business owners, and anyone who wants to build stronger relationships and create a healthier organizational culture through intentional leadership.
Listen to the Episode
About the Hosts
Michael McIntosh is a retired Sheriff, current Division Chief, leadership instructor, and CEO of Integrity Leadership Development. With nearly four decades of law enforcement experience, Mike specializes in leadership development, organizational culture, mentorship, and building high-performing teams. His passion is preparing leaders before promotion so organizations never have to lower their leadership standards.
Cathy McIntosh is a marketing and business strategist with more than 26 years of experience helping organizations build strong brands, develop effective communication strategies, and lead with purpose. As a law enforcement spouse and leadership partner, Cathy brings a unique perspective that connects leadership principles with the human side of service.
Together, Mike and Cathy host Elevate Your Call to Service, where they equip current and future leaders with practical leadership strategies, meaningful conversations, and real-world lessons that strengthen individuals, teams, and organizations.
Related Posts
Episode 59: Why Mentoring Is Important in Leadership: Building Readiness Before Promotion
Episode 60: How Great Leaders Build Resilience and Confidence before Promotion
Episode 61: How to Create Consistent Leadership Standards Across Every Rank
Episode 63: What Are the Signs a Leader Isn't Ready for Promotion?
Ready to Lead at a Higher Level?
If this episode challenged the way you think about leadership, that’s the first step.
The next step is applying it.
👉 Schedule a leadership coaching conversation:
Connect with Us
Follow Mike on LinkedIn: @michael-integrityleaders
Subscribe to Elevate Your Call to Service on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Visit leleaders.com for more resources and to join our leadership community.
Find the full episode on our YouTube channel.
Be sure to grab your free guide: 10 Questions to Consider Before Putting In For Your Next Promotion.