4 Communication Mistakes That Cripple Law Enforcement Leadership
Listen Now:
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Podbean
Law enforcement leadership communication, leadership communication mistakes, police leadership development, clear communication in law enforcement, supervisor communication skills, law enforcement command staff, leadership credibility, communication and trust, law enforcement leadership podcast, Elevate Your Call to Service
Chapters:
00:00 – Welcome to Elevate Your Call to Service
00:48 – Why Communication Shapes Leadership Impact
01:00 – You Can’t Overcommunicate, But You Can Ramble
03:32 – Mistake No. 1: Over-Talking and Overcomplicating the Message
11:00 – Creating Safety for Clarifying Questions
12:12 – Mistake No. 2: Trying to Sound Clever Instead of Clear
16:39 – Mistake No. 3: Communicating Without Clear Next Steps
23:05 – Mistake No. 4: Making Communication About the Leader
29:48 – This Week’s Leadership Challenge
32:00 – Clear Over Clever, People Over Ego
a leader’s most powerful tools: communication
Communication is one of the most powerful tools a leader has—and one of the most misunderstood. In this episode of Elevate Your Call to Service, Mike and Cathy break down four communication mistakes that quietly undermine leadership impact in law enforcement.
From rambling meetings and unclear direction to clever-but-empty language and ego-driven storytelling, these habits often leave teams confused, disengaged, and hesitant to act. Drawing from nearly four decades of law enforcement leadership experience, Mike shares real-world examples of how communication patterns shape trust, morale, and execution—often more than policies or strategy ever will.
This conversation challenges leaders to move from talking at people to involving them, from complexity to clarity, and from performance to service. Whether you supervise a small team or lead at the executive level, this episode provides practical insight to help you communicate with greater purpose, confidence, and effectiveness.
Key Moments
Why clarity consistently outperforms complexity in leadership communication
How long meetings quietly erode morale and credibility
The danger of sounding polished without being clear
Why communication without next steps fails to lead anyone
How insecurity shows up in leadership messaging
The difference between teaching with stories and performing for attention
Why involving people strengthens authority instead of weakening it
Don’t-Miss Highlights
The real reason teams “don’t follow through” after meetings
Why confusion is often misread as laziness
How acronym overload damages trust—internally and with the community
A simple reframing that makes it safer for people to ask clarifying questions
Mike’s perspective on inclusive leadership and decision-making
memorable quotes
“Just saying a lot of words doesn’t mean you’re communicating.”
“If your words aren’t leading people to action, you’re just making noise.”
“Clarity beats complexity every time.”
“Let your leadership speak louder than your resume.”
“Clear over clever. People over ego.”
FAQ: Service-Driven Leadership in Public Safety
Why is communication so important in law enforcement leadership?
Communication shapes clarity, trust, and execution. In law enforcement, unclear or inconsistent communication leads to confusion across shifts, frustration among officers, and missed expectations. Strong leadership communication reduces risk, builds morale, and helps teams act with confidence.
What are the most common communication mistakes leaders make?
The most common mistakes include:
Over-talking and overcomplicating simple messages
Trying to sound clever instead of being clear
Failing to give clear direction and next steps
Making communication about personal credibility rather than the mission and team
These habits quietly undermine leadership impact over time.
Can leaders really overcommunicate?
Leaders can’t overcommunicate clarity—but they can ramble. Using too many words, excessive context, or long meetings without direction causes people to tune out and miss the core messagE.
Why do teams seem disengaged after meetings?
Disengagement often comes from confusion, not lack of motivation. When leaders communicate without clear expectations, ownership, or follow-through, teams are left to improvise. That confusion is frequently misread as laziness or resistance.
What’s the difference between helpful leadership stories and self-focused communication?
Helpful leadership stories illustrate a lesson and serve the team. Self-focused communication uses stories to prove expertise, earn attention, or reinforce authority. The difference is intent: one clarifies the message, the other centers the leader.
How can leaders improve communication starting this week?
Leaders can start by:
Identifying their key message before speaking
Using plain language instead of buzzwords
Clearly defining expectations and next steps
Inviting questions in a way that feels safe
Asking a trusted peer for honest feedback
Small changes in communication habits can lead to immediate improvements in trust and execution.
Related Episodes
Connect with Us
Follow us on Instagram: @lawenforcementleaders
Subscribe to Elevate Your Call to Service on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Visit leleaders.com for more resources and to join our leadership community.
Find the full episode on our YouTube channel.
Be sure to grab your free guide: 10 Questions to Consider Before Putting In For Your Next Promotion.